A common lighting technology in the commercial space is metal halide, at least in the past it was. Businesses are searching for efficient lighting to cut energy usage and reduce overhead.
When facility managers start their search, they often search for the wrong answer. Here are some common questions that get asked:
“How many LED watts does it take to replace a 1000 watt metal halide bulb?”
“How can I replace my metal halide light?”
“Is it even possible to replace my metal halide fixture with another technology?”
This post will cover the first question. We describe in detail the process and guidelines to replace 1000W HID Lights with LED.
How many LED watts does it take to replace a 1000 watt metal halide?
It’s a simple question that requires a complex answer. You can’t base your decision entirely off of watts. Instead, you need to base your decision based on the amount of lumens you need. Once you get the lumens dialed in, find a fixture that produces that lumen amount.
What is a lumen?
In simple terms, it’s a unit or measurement of light. For light fixtures, we calculate the total lumen output. That tells us how bright the fixture will be.
Why does this matter? A lot more than you may think. Because it’s what matters when replacing old light systems.
When replacing an existing fixture, determine the lumen output per fixture. Metal halide fixtures, with fresh bulbs, output at 100,000 (initial) lumens per 1000 watt bulb. You do not need to replace 1000W Metal Halide with 1000W LED. Instead, you need to find the equivalent replacement for the 100,000 lumens. You can forget about replacing watts and focus on replacing lumens.
In the above example, 1000W producing 100,000 lumens, the effiency is 100 lumens per watt. In the world of today’s lighting, this is OK, but not great. You need to be aware of some other factors going on.
Understanding Initial Lumens and L70
100,000 lumens may seem bright. It is. Metal Halide bulbs have high initial output. They suffer from fast lumen depreciation. It is common for a metal halide bulb to have lost 50% of it’s lumens at half-life.
L70 is a term for the number of hours before a bulb is performing at 70% of initial lumen output. For metal halide, 70% of its lumen output calculates to about 5000 hours. So, while the specs say 100,000 lumens, it won’t be 100,000 lumens for long. LED maintains its lumens much better.
You will notice L70 times for LEDs are 50,000 and 100,000 hours, not 5,000 hours like it is for metal halide bulbs.
Loss of Light due to Reflection
LED light is directional. HID light sources are omni-directional and need reflectors to focus light. Any reflected lumen that bounces more than once is a lost lumen. Studies show that you can lose up to 30% of the effective lumens in the reflective process.
If a metal halide bulb has 100,000 initial lumens, the loss associated to reflected lumen bounce is around 30,000 lumens.
Quality of Lumens
This relates to Color Rendering Index, or CRI. Its a measurement of quality, not quantity. The higher the quality, the less quantity you need. Often, customers tell us that 20,000 LED lumens appear brighter than 40,000 HID lumens.
The basic truth is you need less quantity when you have higher quality.
Photopic vs Scotopic Lumens
This has to do with how a camera perceives lumens versus how humans perceive lumens. Photopic lumens is light detected by a light meter or camera. Scotopic lumens are lumens detected by the human eye. LED produces visible scotpic light. It is rare to see a LED light produce IR or UV invisible spectrums. These wavelengths are invisible to people, so they have no value to us from a vision perspective. Light meters detect invisible spectrums, giving a false perception of brightness.
The science of scotopic lumens includes a factor used to adjust the photopic value to give a true representation of how “good” the lumens are. This factor is the S/P ratio. The S/P ratio attempts to level lumen quality between light sources. The factor adjusts the effective value of lumens, up or down, from the photopic lumens.
Assume you have an 40,000 lumen high-pressure sodium (HPS) fixture and a 12,000 lumen LED fixture. Is the LED fixture capable of replacing the HPS fixture? Based on this data, you may think that the LED will only deliver 25% of the light provided by the HPS light. Consider the following S/P ratios:
- LED S/P ratio = 2.0
- HPS S/P ratio = 0.5
The scotopic lumens provided by each light source would be the following:
- LED scotopic lumens = 12,000 lm x 2.0 = 24,000 lm
- HPS scotopic lumens = 40,000 lm x 0.5 = 20,000 lm
- The LED would appear brighter even though it is 28,000 less lumens.
Light sources with higher scotopic factors need less lumens for us to perceive and detect the light.
Putting This All Together
The basic takeaway from this is you need far fewer LED lumens than metal halide or HPS lumens.
- Metal Halide bulbs are very bright out of the box, but degrade quickly.
- LED light is directional. LED light goes where its pointed. It is very efficient.
- LED light is high quality light. You need less quantity.
So how much LED Lumens do you need?
Only a photometric can tell you exactly how much you need. But in our 10+ years of selling LED lighting, our general rule of thumb is:
Indoors: 45,000 to 65,000 lumens (depends on application and mounting height)
Outdoors: 40,000 to 75,000 lumens (depends on application and mounting height)
By searching for LED to replace 1000W HID you can find LEDs that are more efficient than 100 lumens/watt. Lumen efficiency for LED is getting closer to 200 lm/watts. This will allow a cut of watts used by 75% or more.
But What Does “replacing” Consist of?
Replacing can consist of two things: retrofitting or full replacement. The difference is simple, a retrofit kit is like replacing the light source in the fixture. While full replacement includes replacing the existing light source and fixture. To be able to decide which one is best for you will depend on your facilities’ situation. If your existing fixture shell is in good condition, retrofitting will work. If they are old, outdated and need replacing, a full replacement is the best option.
Are the LEDs in a retrofit kit as good as a LED fixture
Yes. Despite of what you have heard, there is no reason to believe that a retrofit/hid replacement won’t perform or last as long as a new fixture. Retrofits don’t always make sense. But they do if you have a significant investment in your fixture or the look of your fixture. Our retrofit kits have 10 year warranties. They have been installed inside sealed fixtures in hot locations, like Arizona, Nevada, California and even in the Middle East.
It is possible to replace a metal halide fixture with LED technology. It can be as simple as retrofitting or replacing your existing fixtures.
An investment in LED will have pay backs in many ways. It includes lower energy usage, lower maintenance costs and higher quality of light produced.